Creative agency glossarySEO and Analytics

Google Dance

The Google Dance was the period of ranking turbulence that occurred each month in Google's early years while a rebuilt index rolled out across its data centers.

What is the Google Dance?

The Google Dance was a monthly event. In the early 2000s Google rebuilt its index roughly every four weeks and pushed the new version out to its data centers over several days. During that window, different data centers served different indexes, so a query could return one ranking one minute and another the next, depending on which server answered. Rankings jumped, fell and settled, and site owners watched them the way sailors watch weather.

The name was partly a joke and partly a party: Google hosted an actual Google Dance for webmasters at a search conference for several years. The phenomenon faded as Google moved to more continuous updating around 2003, and the Caffeine indexing system of 2010 removed the last of it.

Why it matters

Why the Google Dance matters

It matters as history, because it explains habits the industry still has. The ritual of checking rankings daily, the anxiety around updates, the folklore of waiting for things to settle all come from a time when rankings genuinely did convulse on a schedule. Knowing that the schedule is gone helps a team read today's fluctuations for what they are.

It matters as a comparison, too. Today's equivalent is the volatility around a core update, which Google announces, rolls out over days or weeks, and which changes rankings for real reasons. The Dance was noise from a mechanical process; a core update is signal about quality. Treating the second like the first, as something to wait out, is how sites miss the message.

In practice

How the Google Dance works in practice

  1. 01

    The mechanics were a consequence of scale. Rebuilding the index meant recomputing PageRank and the rest from scratch, and pushing the result to many data centers could not happen at once. Tools of the time let you query each data center by address to see which index it was serving, and forums filled with people comparing them and guessing when the rollout would finish.

  2. 02

    What replaced it was incremental updating: adding and refreshing pages continuously, so there is never a wholesale swap. The lesson that survives is how to behave when rankings move. Check whether Google has announced an update. Look at whether the movement is sitewide or confined to a set of pages. Give a known update time to finish rolling out before reacting, then look at what the affected pages have in common. The reflex to wait is right; the reflex to wait and do nothing is not.

Watch out

What people get wrong about the Google Dance

Using the term for today's fluctuations. Daily movement in rankings now reflects testing, personalization, competition and the continuous crawl, not a scheduled rebuild, and calling it a dance suggests a cause that no longer exists. The second mistake is the inverse: assuming the Dance era's wisdom, that everything settles if you wait, still holds. A drop after a core update will not reverse on its own if the pages that dropped deserved it.

Questions

People also ask

Does the Google Dance still happen?

Not in its original form. Google updates its index continuously, so there is no monthly rebuild and no window in which data centers disagree. Ranking fluctuations now come from core updates, testing and competition rather than from a scheduled rollout.

When was the Google Dance?

Roughly from Google's early years through 2003, when the index was rebuilt about once a month. Continuous updating reduced it after that, and the Caffeine infrastructure in 2010 ended it.

What causes ranking fluctuations today?

Announced core and spam updates, ongoing experiments Google runs with its results, personalization and location, new competition, and changes on your own site. Checking Google's update announcements is the first step in telling which one you are seeing.

Next to it in the glossary

  1. Google BombingGoogle bombing is the manipulation of search rankings by pointing many links with the same anchor text at a page so that it ranks for a phrase it has nothing to do with.
  2. Google Business ProfileGoogle Business Profile is the free listing that controls how a business appears in Google Search and Google Maps.
  3. Google CaffeineGoogle Caffeine was a 2010 rebuild of Google's indexing system that let new pages and updates appear in search results within minutes rather than weeks.
  4. Google DiscoverGoogle Discover is a personalized content feed on mobile that shows articles and videos to people based on their interests, without a search query.
  5. Google HummingbirdGoogle Hummingbird was a 2013 rewrite of Google's core search algorithm that shifted ranking from matching keywords toward understanding the meaning of a whole query.
  6. Google Keyword PlannerGoogle Keyword Planner is a free tool inside Google Ads that shows search volumes, forecasts and keyword ideas for terms people search on Google.

Every SEO and Analytics term →

In the work

Where it shows up

All our creations →

From the journal

Read around it

The journal →

Talking the talk is one thing

We make the work.

RIOT is a creative agency and production studio in New York. Strategy, brand, film, photography, design and the campaigns that carry them, made by one team. A few lines is enough to start: we read every brief the same day.

    Footage